Where a single-minus gluon tree amplitude survives
One negative-helicity gluon and three positive-helicity gluons have a vanishing tree amplitude at generic momenta. In real split signature, a distribution supported on half-collinear momenta can survive. Its coefficient changes as the momenta cross chamber boundaries.
Where the usual vanishing argument breaks
Write each massless momentum as an undotted spinor times a dotted one. Angle brackets contract the first pair of spinors and square brackets the second. For generic momenta, using the negative-helicity leg as a reference spinor for the positive-helicity polarizations makes the usual tree-level vanishing argument work. On the half-collinear locus every angle bracket vanishes. That reference choice now divides by zero.
In real signature (2,2), square brackets can still differ from zero on this locus. Guevara and colleagues derive a color-ordered amplitude whose delta functions enforce half-collinearity and momentum conservation. The quantity to compare between allowed momenta is the coefficient that remains after those factors and the helicity prefactor are removed.
A four-point chamber coefficient
Take leg 1 to have negative helicity and the other three to have positive helicity. Work in the decay region R₁, where a frame exists with negative frequency for leg 1 and positive frequencies for the remaining legs. In this region the authors reduce their recursion to a product of signs. For four legs it has two factors.
Write sᵢⱼ for the sign of the square bracket of legs i and j. In s₁,₂₃ the second spinor is the sum of the dotted spinors of legs 2 and 3. Each sign is constant until its bracket crosses zero. The equation therefore assigns a constant coefficient to the interior of each chamber.
From recursion to a product
The Berends–Giele recursion builds currents from lower-point currents. Its four-point coefficient, Eq. (30), is already short. At higher multiplicity the recursion yields many more terms. The all-multiplicity product in Eq. (39) gives a compact answer in R₁. The authors credit GPT-5.2 Pro with conjecturing that formula and an internal OpenAI model with producing a proof. They report checking the solution by hand against the recursion.
Comparing two expressions at the same momenta
Our exact calculation compared the four-point recursion result to the four-point specialization of the product. We set all undotted spinors to (1,0), chose positive frequencies for legs 2 through 4, and fixed the dotted spinor of leg 1 by momentum conservation. With dotted spinors (−6,−4), (1,−2), (2,0), (3,6), both expressions give +1.
Across twelve retained inputs we found four values each of +1, −1 and 0, with agreement at every point. Six additional inputs had a vanishing pair bracket and were excluded. Reversing the sign of one term in Eq. (30) produced a discrepancy at every retained point. The linked calculation gives the spinors and the code for repeating the comparison.
Limits of this result
- The calculation concerns a real split-signature distribution on special kinematics. Generic Lorentzian scattering remains outside this result.
- The equations and numbering follow arXiv v2. Footnote 6 leaves the continuation to complex momenta open.
Checks performed
Exact evaluation on half-collinear momenta
Evaluated Eqs. (30) and (39) for four external gluons on twelve chamber-interior inputs in R₁, using an independently written script. This checks sampled coefficients. The distributional derivation and all-multiplicity proof were outside the calculation.
Sources & citations
- Single-minus gluon tree amplitudes are nonzeroAlfredo Guevara, Alexandru Lupsasca, David Skinner, Andrew Strominger and Kevin Weil · 2026-03-09
arXiv:2602.12176v2. Introduction, model and author contributions. Eqs. (2)–(5), spinor frame. §I.1, Eqs. (13)–(16) and footnote 6, support and signature. §I.4, Eq. (30), four-point coefficient. §§II.1–3, Eqs. (33) and (39), decay region and product.
Index terms single-minus · single minus · half-collinear · helicity · gluon · Klein signature · split signature · Berends–Giele recursion · GPT-5.2 Pro · arXiv:2602.12176