Calculations / Scattering amplitudes
Worked calculation

Comparing two four-gluon single-minus formulas

Two expressions for the stripped four-point coefficient are compared on half-collinear kinematics.

Executed

Restrict the kinematics

Use cyclic color order (1, 2, 3, 4), with the negative helicity on leg 1. In the real split-signature frame of Eq. (2), set every undotted spinor to (1, 0). The angle brackets then vanish. Choose three outgoing dotted spinors with positive frequencies. Set the incoming dotted spinor equal to minus their sum. This enforces momentum conservation and places the example in the decay region R₁.

The square bracket convention in Eq. (5) fixes the relative signs. For dotted spinors written as (u, v), evaluate [ij] = vᵢuⱼ − uᵢvⱼ. The script computes the four-point sign sum in Eq. (30) and, independently, the product of sign factors in Eq. (39) with its partial sums of dotted spinors.

Read one point by hand

Take dotted spinors (−6, −4), (1, −2), (2, 0), (3, 6) in leg order. The brackets [23], [41], [12], [34] are −4, −24, −16, −12. Each pair of signs in Eq. (30) contributes +1. Dividing their sum by two gives +1. The Eq. (39) product also gives +1.

Results away from sign walls

Permuting three slopes for three sets of positive frequencies gives 18 inputs. The code excludes 6 inputs at which any pair bracket vanishes. The two formulas agree at all 12 remaining inputs.

Recorded stripped coefficient
CoefficientNumber of inputs
-14
04
14

Flipping the sign of the second term in Eq. (30) produces 12 disagreements with the original product. These samples check the stripped four-point coefficient in this frame. They leave the distributional factors and higher multiplicities unevaluated.

Repeat the calculation

Save the Python script and recorded output (JSON) in the same directory. The site ran the script with CPython 3.12.14 and its standard library. The calculation uses exact arithmetic and completes in under a second.

python3 -I check.py > rerun.json
cmp result.json rerun.json

A successful comparison exits with status zero. The output includes the inputs and individual checks.

Sources and interpretation

Single-minus gluon tree amplitudes are nonzero. arXiv:2602.12176v2. Introduction, model and author contributions. Eqs. (2)–(5), spinor frame. §I.1, Eqs. (13)–(16) and footnote 6, support and signature. §I.4, Eq. (30), four-point coefficient. §§II.1–3, Eqs. (33) and (39), decay region and product.

Read the research entry for the role of AI in the original work and the range of its conclusions.